In short
- Keep treats under about 10% of your dog's daily calories.
- Use pea-sized pieces of a smelly, easy-to-snap treat.
- Train in short sessions, and avoid sugar, colours and big biscuits.
How many treats a day? Fewer than you think, and smaller than you think. The rule of thumb printed on most treat bags, and the one we use at home, is to keep treats under about 10% of your dog's daily calories. Vets' groups such as WSAVA use the same rule.
For Brownie, our 4kg Miniature Poodle, that is a very small pile. So the secret to training well is not more treats. It is tinier pieces of better treats, handed out at the right moment.
In this article
How many treats a day is too many?
Treats are food, and your dog's body counts them even when you don't. Every piece of chicken at the table, every "good boy" biscuit from a neighbour at the void deck, and every reward during a walk goes into the same stomach as dinner. The 10% guideline is a budget, not a target. On a heavy training day, take a little out of the evening meal to balance it.

The practical fix is to decide the day's treat ration in the morning and put it in a small container. When the container is empty, switch to praise, play or a few pieces of your dog's own kibble.
With many overweight small dogs, dinner is not the problem. It is a normal dinner plus a second dinner's worth of snacks nobody wrote down.
If your dog is overweight, on a prescription diet or has a condition like pancreatitis or kidney disease, ask your vet which treats are fine and how much. Do this before you start a training programme.
Pea-sized is the right size
A training treat should disappear in about a second. If your dog has to chew, look for crumbs, or lick the floor, you lose the link between the behaviour and the reward, and the session drags. Break every treat into pieces the size of a pea, or smaller for a chihuahua or a kitten.
For training, a tasty treat matters more than a big one. One heart-shaped treat snapped into six pieces gives you six "yes" moments instead of one, and your daily budget stretches six times further. For a very small dog, you can even scrape a treat with your thumbnail and reward with the crumbs.
What makes a treat good for training
- Snaps or crumbles easily. You should be able to break it with one hand while holding the lead with the other.
- Smells like something. Dogs train for aroma. Bland, dry biscuits don't earn much effort at the park connector when there are mynahs to chase.
- A short label. One ingredient is ideal. If the first ingredient is wheat flour, you are paying for a cracker with a meat scent.
- Survives your pocket. Soft, sticky treats go mushy quickly in our humidity. Freeze-dried or dried treats stay usable.
- Not something they get anyway. A treat only works as a reward if it is better than what the dog gets for free.
Low value, high value
Keep two tiers. For easy things at home, like sits before dinner or going into the crate, use pieces of your dog's own kibble or a plain veggie chip.
Save the smelly, meaty pieces for the hard things. That means recall when a cat appears, walking past the hawker centre bins, or staying calm when the lift opens. If every behaviour earns the best treat, the best treat stops being special.
What to avoid
- Added sugar. Syrups, molasses and honey show up surprisingly often in soft treats. Glycerin, used to keep them soft, adds sweetness and calories too.
- Artificial colours. Your dog does not care that a treat is red. Colour is there for you.
- Big biscuits. One large biscuit can be a meaningful chunk of a small dog's daily intake. Use them as a once-a-day chew, not a training reward.
- Long chews during training. Dental sticks and bully sticks are great for settling a dog. But a reward that takes ten minutes to finish ends the session.
- Table food. Char siew, satay and fried chicken skin are salty and fatty. Some human foods are also unsafe for dogs: grapes and raisins, onion and garlic, chocolate, macadamia nuts, and anything sweetened with xylitol.
- Treats that have gone soft. If a dried treat bends or smells off, the humidity has got to it. Bin it.
Training in the tropical heat
A hot, panting dog is a distracted dog. Keep sessions to three to five minutes. Train indoors with a fan or the aircon running, or outside in the early morning and after sunset. Put the water bowl down before you start. If you train right after a walk, give your dog a few minutes on a cool tile floor first.

Stop while your dog is still keen. Short sessions with breaks in between work better than one long session, and they use fewer treats.
Get more out of every treat
Timing matters more than the treat itself. Say your marker word ("yes" works) the instant the behaviour happens. Then deliver the piece within a second. Reward the sit before the bottom lifts off the floor again.
Once a behaviour is reliable, slowly start rewarding some repetitions instead of every one. Rewards that come now and then help a learned behaviour last.
You can also turn dinner into a training session. Hand-feed part of the meal for sits, downs and a hand touch, or scatter it across the floor for a sniffing game. That is training with zero extra food.
Why these two are on our shelf
When we picked treats for Mitodo Picks, we wanted labels we could read in one breath, and pieces small enough for Waffle, our 2.8kg Maltipoo and Head of Napping Research. Two made the cut.

Small Batch Freeze-Dried Heart Treats (3.5 oz, S$18) have exactly one ingredient: freeze-dried heart from humanely raised animals. Each bag is a single protein, so there are five to choose from: chicken, turkey, lamb, pork and beef.
They snap into tiny pieces, so one heart becomes several rewards. Because they are freeze-dried rather than cooked, they hold up in a pocket. Our pawbies learned "sit" faster with these than with anything else. Suspiciously fast. They are raw, so wash your hands after a session. Keep the bag sealed somewhere cool and dry.
Arlo Kitchen Veggie Chips (S$9.90) are our low-value tier. Each bag is 100% of one Korean-grown vegetable, dried into a crisp chip, with no sweeteners, colourings or preservatives. Choose watermelon radish, okra or kohlrabi. They are light and crunchy, and easy to break into tiny bits. The label gives a clear daily amount as a treat:
| Body weight | Veggie chips per day |
|---|---|
| Up to 3 kg | About 1 g |
| 3–5 kg | 1–2 g |
| 5–10 kg | 2–5 g |
| Over 10 kg | 5–10 g |
One thing to know: there are no preservatives, so the chips are sensitive to heat and humidity. Once opened, keep the bag zipped, store it in the fridge and use it within a month. Don't feed the silica gel sachet.
Tonight, do one thing. Take tomorrow's treat ration out of the bag, break it into pea-sized pieces and put it in a small container by the door. Everything your dog learns tomorrow will come out of that container, and nothing more.